With effect from Friday, September 3 2010 Dr Patel is no longer instructed, requested or directed to perform autopsies under The Coroners Act 1988 by HM Coroner for The Inner North District of Greater London (Camden, Hackney, Islington and Tower Hamlets).. He is arrested again in 1998 when a prostitute accuses him of raping her. Mr Justice Keith, sitting in London, said: "This is one of those exceptionally rare cases in which life should mean life. In the room the police found the naked dead body of a woman lying on a bed with cuts and bruises to her head. It has taken nine years and other high-profile cases, notably the death of newspaper seller Ian Tomlinson at the G20 protests, which Dr Patel worked on, for the General Medical Council to reach this stage in its investigation into Dr Patels conclusions. Whilst in custody Hardy was transferred to a psychiatric hospital, under section 37 of the Mental Health Act 1983, remaining there until November 2002.[11]. As the pathologist who wrongly concluded a murder victim died of natural causes is suspended, the New Journals RICHARD OSLEY looks back on the case he has followed since the inquest into Sally Whites death in 2002. Similarly, 35-year-old Bridgette MacClennan is identified through DNA. Unable to find the victims head or hands, police are forced to use the serial number of her breast implants to identify the victim as 31-year-old prostitute, Elizabeth Valad. The panel also found proved allegations he did not consider the presence and location of blood staining on the deceased's clothing and bedding, plus the presence of a warm bucket of water next to her body. In November 2003, he was given three life sentences. Jackie Valad believes her daughter Elizabeth would still be alive if Patel had not concluded in his initial report that White had died of natural causes, because a police investigation would have been launched. Later in the same documentary, images of the crime scene, including a blurred photo of Ms Whites body are included. March 2002 Hardy is sent to St Lukes psychiatric hospital in north London after a dispute with a neighbour. In that play, now anA-level standard text for English literature students, JB Priestley created a cast who each in turn shift uneasily when questioned over the death of a desperate factory girl. ]]> During an interview another health worker said: I remember a number of reactions. by CHARLOTTE CHAMBERS. And they were right. It is what the statement omitted to say that causes us concern. The panel ruled that Dr Patel, 63, had taken an inflexible approach to his autopsy and gave only superficial consideration to the possibility Ms White had been strangled. Patel decided that White, a 31-year-old sex worker, had died of natural causes despite blood staining her clothing, bedding and a wall at Hardy's flat. Hardys strange behaviour raises concerns about his mental health and he is diagnosed with bi-polar disorder. Then he drags her to a bath and tries to drown her. She was such a beautiful girl. Camden New Journal I havent got them, so therefore they would have been shredded. [20] The other man was stocky and wearing dark clothing. Dr Patel Again * Inquiries into the doctor began after the Camden Ripper Anthony Hardy was caught in 2003. Hints and tips West End Extra, 40 Camden Road Camden Town London, NW1 9DR, Enquiries: As the pathologist who wrongly concluded a murder victim died of natural causes is suspended, the New Journals RICHARD OSLEY looks back on the case he has followed since the inquest into Sally Whites death in 2002. A dinner-table circle of consciences are pricked, from the mill owner who made her redundant to the haughty charity worker who turns her away when she seeks help, as the opportunities to change her life before suicide are recounted. A PATHOLOGIST who carried out hundreds of post mortems on Camden residents will no longer be used by the boroughs coroner after being suspended by a regulatory panel. In a Channel 4 documentary, The Hunt for the Camden Ripper, made after Hardys conviction, Detective Inspector Alan Bostock is asked why the Sally White investigation was brought to a close. Now, Dr Patels case has been resolved at the GMC, the Camden Ripper files may never be reopened again. There were so many questions to be answered, the Valad familys case was nevertheless thrown out at the High Court. The National Policing Improvement Agency (NPIA), a regulatory body for pathologists on the Home Office register, suspended Dr Patel from conducting suspicious death post mortems last year. Instead of a full statement detailing the curious circumstances in which Ms Whites body was found, police handed over what amounted to basic details for the sole intention of getting Ms Whites body released. The flat was owned by Anthony Hardy - a serial killer known as the Camden Ripper - who went on to kill two more victims after police took no action against him regarding Miss White. Jan 2002 Police are called in to investigate an attack at Hardys neighbour flat. The location is yards from the council estate in North London where Hardy had made his home for the past three years. On 30 December 2002, a homeless person scavenging in rubbish bins found the dismembered body parts of two women, wrapped in black plastic bin-liners. She was identified as Sally White, 38, a prostitute who had been living in London. Patel declared she died of natural causes, and as a result a murder investigation was not begun till much later, during which time two other murders had been committed by the same man. Anthony Hardy- Serial Killer - Murder in the Uk . It was all too suspicious for some. It was Mrs Valad who campaigned for a full public inquiry into how Hardy was not caught before her daughter was killed and why he was released from a locked mental health institution just weeks before the murder. The panel found Patel failed to consider key evidence including the blood staining on her clothing and bedding or fully to consider that her body had been found in a locked room in the flat of a recently-arrested man, or another sex worker's statement that Hardy had nearly suffocated her. During an interview another health worker said: I remember a number of reactions. The pathologist has also been found guilty of dishonesty by providing the GMC with a false CV in 2009. It was Mrs Valad who campaigned for a full public inquiry into how Hardy was not caught before her daughter was killed and why he was released from a locked mental health institution just weeks before the murder. Hardy replies no comment. The coroner had no other way of knowing these things. Police officers who became serial killers, Take part in our survey to win an Amazon Fire HD 8 and Amazon Echo Dot. G20 pathologist Freddy Patel suspended - the Guardian Under arrest, Hardy simply replied "no comment" to every question put to him by police. Charges are later dropped 1986 The marriage breaks down and Hardy returns to London alone But Dr Chan, according to the health authoritys investigation, had not been given the full picture; not only by Dr Patels attempt to establish how Ms White had died, but by the police as well. Between April and November 2002, Hardy spent time in psychiatric units at several hospitals, and within six weeks of being released he murdered Elizabeth Valad and Bridgette MacClennan. One was, thats daft, how does the body of a woman get into somebodys flat? Then there was a relief and it was a mixture of thats all right then, he hasnt murdered somebody but hang on a minute, its not quite all right., The interviewer asked: In your own mind, putting it at its lowest, it remained a possibility that it was murder and that he had got away with it?. When the police investigated Hardy's flat, they found a locked door and, despite his claims to the contrary, found that Hardy had a key to it. It did not mention the clothing that had apparently been cut from Sally Whites body when she was dead. A lot of mistakes were made.. Design by. Dr Patel was the pathologist blamed for the decision not to prosceute the police officer involved in the death of Ian Tomlinson during the G20 protests in April 2009. Dr Freddy Patel, who had been on a government register of accredited pathologists, was suspended on June 2 The panel said it did not want to speculate on what might have happened if Dr Chan had been briefed differently but its report added: The effect of the police statement was to close off any further inquiry by the coroner It conveyed a misleading and unduly reassuring impression about the circumstances., The Metropolitan Police did answer this criticism, insisting the detectives involved were never asked to attend the inquest, although it conceded: Regrettably, for an unascertainable reason, the letter sent to the coroner for the purposes of releasing Sally Whites body was tendered in evidence and the wider concerns of the investigative team were not fully brought before the coroner.. I get paid to investigate unexplained deaths, suspicious deaths not deaths by natural causes. Serial Killer: Anthony Hardy (The Camden Ripper) - YouTube After he left St Pancras Coroners Court, the New Journal was told by officials at the court he had left no forwarding address for our enquiries. advertising@camdennewjournal.com. As such only a small number know what happened in the sessions organised by the North Central London Strategic Health Authority and Camden Council, beyond their published findings. This was not the first time that Hardy had used the level of sadistic violence he that had employed in the killing and dismemberment of Elizabeth and Bridgette. "Hardy claimed he was a 'gregarious, intelligent, well- trusted man' until he was made redundant and divorced in the 1980s" Martin Beckford, Court News UK John Anthony Hardy is born in 1951 in the small town of Burton- upon-Trent in Staffordshire. Dr Patels barrister, Adrian Hopkins, accused the GMC of sitting on their hands and, after 2005, inexplicably putting the White case on ice while it continued to investigate the other charges. freddy patel camden ripper Dr Freddy Patel, who has been criticised for his part in the investigation into the death of Ian Tomlinson during the G20 protests, has been facing a General Medical Council hearing over his. Mr Davies said it would be unfair and cause prejudice to Dr Patel should the White case be heard. Patel accepted that he did not adequately report on other possible causes of the marks of injury or their possible significance. A priceless chance was lost when Sally White, now identified as Hardys first known victim, was discovered dead in his back room nearly a year before the deaths of Ms Valad and Ms MacClennan, two women who worked as prostitutes. [18][22] The torso was found next to Chelsea Harbour on the Thames. Hardy said an alcohol-induced blackout meant he could not recall how Ms Whites body ended up in his room. [10], Hardy pleaded guilty to a charge of criminal damage and claimed he had no knowledge of how White came to be in his flat due to his drinking problem. Timeline | Crime + Investigation UK I never got over it. Murder Mile UK True-Crime Podcast #119: The Four Faces of The Camden Dr Chan also listened to a report from a housing worker and then Dr Patel gave evidence from the witness box. He became an alcoholic and diabetic.[6]. . As Hardy pleaded guilty, there was no trial and no fresh coroners inquests were ever conducted. A number of the other allegations however, were found to be not proved. I never got over it. The dismembered remains of the two other victims were found in December that year in bin bags near his home in north London. He failed to comment on whether a blunt force injury which caused a large gash to White's head might have knocked her unconscious. The . Ian Tomlinson tribunal: pathologist failed in main areas, says expert Dr Patel ruled a naked and bruised woman found in Hardy's flat a year earlier had died from a heart attack. The document, however, suggests there were areas of concern beyond the work of the pathologist. but not charged with Sally's murder. She added in that interview with the Nottingham Evening Post that she felt the case had been subject to a whitewash. Dec 2002 The dismembered body parts of Bridgette MacClennan and Elizabeth Valad are discovered, Dec 2002 Police find Elizabeth Valads torso in Hardys London flat, Jan 2003 Police arrest Hardy at Great Ormond Street hospital in London, Nov 2003 Hardys trial begins. Ultimately, the health authorities were cleared of any wrongdoing. Elizabeth Valad 29 yrs: 1973 to 30.12.2002 Elizabeth Valad, the beautiful daughter of American University lecturer Hasan and Jackie Valad. After taking legal advice, panel chairman Richard Davies ruled that the case referred to as case E could not be heard as correct procedures had not been followed in its preparation. Had these matters been communicated to the coroner we think it likely that he would not so easily have been satisfied that there was no third-party investigation or foul play.. Alan Bostock asks his suspect about the incriminating photographs found in his flat. However, the GMC hearing found that Dr Patels findings did not properly take into account the location and position of the victims body in a locked room owned by a man recently arrested by police, nor did he consider the presence of blood on the deceaseds clothing and why a bucket of warm water was located next to the body. The GMC ruled that Patel made a string of errors and failed to fully consider the circumstances of White's death. Lawal set for Elite test after latest win, Road less travelled in Women Behind the Wheel, New Journal Enterprises 2023. It follows the panels investigation into three cases dating from 2003 to 2005. Islington Tribune Hardy killed Sally White in January 2002. Pathologist Freddy Patel handed suspension | The - The Independent It emerged that he had made errors in a number of cases, including that of Sally White. Dr Patel denies the misconduct charges and insists he was not criticised over the Hardy case. Forensic pathologists will now carry out no less than 20 and no more than 95 forensic post mortems in any 12-month period, to ensure quality is not affected by over work or under use. The whole team had a gut feeling he had done it., While they held these fears, there was no official outlet or investigation for them to share them with. What would the playwright have made of the murders of Anthony Hardy? Hardy, despite a history of mental illness, a personality disorder and schizophrenia, was said to have been bad, not mad at the time of his killings. freddy patel camden ripperapplebee's ashland menu. The cause of death was given as coronary heart disease, which we refer to as natural causes. The hearing continued yesterday (Wednesday). Would a budding Columbo have learned that the pathologist and the coroner believed Ms Whites death was due to heart problems and left it at that? Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window). and although they took the very rare step of requesting a second autopsy be conducted, Dr Freddy Patel returned with the same conclusion - "heart failure". In January 2002, police were called to the block of flats where Hardy lived by a neighbour complaining that someone had vandalised her front door and that she strongly suspected Hardy. In what seems contrary to the physical evidence, and the polices expectations, the pathologist, Freddy Patel, deems the cause of death as a heart attack. Not suspicious. He was suspended from carrying out routine post mortems for three months. Previous case: Dr Patel was also criticised over his investigation into the death of G20 protester Ian Tomlinson. Photograph: Fiona Hanson/PA, suspended from the register for three months last September. [22][23] She was said to have often started up conversations with strangers. There is mention of Dr Patels work in their final report, published in September 2005. In his concluding remarks, Dr Chan said: She [Sally White] died as a result of coronary artery disease. Retired police officer Mike Burrowes, recognises the man the press were calling the Camden Ripper and he calls detectives.Police arrest Hardy in a waiting room at Great Ormond Street hospital and begin questioning him. Anthony Hardy Explained [20] Investigators also asked for a woman named Carmen or Carmel to come forward as they believed she had information on the murder, saying she was apparently a friend of Parker and came from the Hounslow or Isleworth area. At 11am, at St Pancras Mortuary, an autopsy by Dr Freddy Patel confirmed their worst fears; the legs were human, female, recently dismembered and more than likely belonged to more than one woman. Looking back, it is amazing to think it was all over in 15 minutes. But Dr Chan, according to the health authoritys investigation, had not been given the full picture; not only by Dr Patels attempt to establish how Ms White had died, but by the police as well. The GMC will now hear submissions as to whether, in light of the proven facts against him, Dr Patels ability to practice has been impaired and what sanctions will be taken against him. //-->Anthony Hardy: The Camden Ripper | Crime + Investigation UK THERE is a touch of An Inspector Calls about the dark tragedies which unfolded on the College Place estate nearly a decade ago. Through days of harrowing evidence, Hardy is revealed to the jury as a man who is a pornography-obsessed necrophiliac who achieves sexual gratification by posing the nude bodies of his victims after death and taking explicit photos of their naked corpses.The jury delivers a verdict of guilty to all three counts. Having been on the New Journal for four months, Iwas sitting in court that day as a cub reporter still getting used to the inquest system that most people have no knowledge of unless a relative or friend dies in unusual circumstances. A forensic pathologist has told a panel that disgraced pathologist Dr Freddy Patel had failed in two main areas during his postmortem examination of Ian Tomlinson, the newspaper vendor who was. [21] She was 24 years old and was also known as Cathy Dennis. Hardy was the subject of a Channel 4 documentary, The Hunt for the Camden Ripper, broadcast in 2004. I'm a vet, and here are five dog breeds most prone to cancer - including Golden Retrievers and Rottweilers. Camden Ripper: Baffling tragedy of how killer was freed to murder again There was no mention of the presence of the bucket of warm water in the room where Sally Whites body was found, which proved Mr Hardy was lying when he denied any knowledge of her presence in his flat. Hardy was given three life sentences in November 2003 for the murders of three women, including White. Police shut down a potential murder inquiry against Hardy after Dr Patels findings. Simon Jackson QC, the GMCs barrister, had argued that it was in the public interest that the case be adjudicated on. A search of the flat uncovers vital evidence which will help to convict Hardy of the three horrific murders.In an attempt to uncover what had happened in the flat, police use a cutting edge forensic system called luminol, a process which reveals blood stains that cant be seen by the human eye. You dont need too many powers of deduction to work out he is the man identified only as Dr Y. Updated 23:46, 31 MAR 2011. or debate this issue live on our message boards. All of it would have been packaged up in a natural causes file. Investigations into Dr Patels professional work stretch back 12 years. Hardy drifted after his divorce living in various hostels around London, he also spent time in various mental hospitals, diagnosed with bipolar disorder. That was the final part of this four-part series into The Camden Ripper and the final episode of Murder Mile for 2020. The cause of death was given as coronary heart disease, which we refer to as natural causes. [4], After the divorce, Hardy spent time in mental hospitals, diagnosed with bipolar disorder. THERE is a touch of An Inspector Calls about the dark tragedies which unfolded on the College Place estate nearly a decade ago. Bungling G20 Tomlinson pathologist is under fire again over [21], Parker's incomplete body had been found on 17 December 2000, 11 days after she disappeared. A fight took place as he resisted arrest, during the course of which a police officer was knocked unconscious and another officer was stabbed through the hand and had his eye dislocated from its socket. The honeytrap plot that left father-of-six dead: Moment two women lead victim into his flat to seduce him 'Sonic boom' is heard across central England as 'ground shakes' and houses are rocked. Camden New Journal "Hardy is a dangerous, devious and manipulative man. After being caught he was tried and jailed for life after pleading guilty to all three murders, despite Dr Patels findings. I will accept this as the medical cause of her death, so there really is no other conclusion than to conclude this inquiry by recording a verdict that she died as a result of natural causes.. Hardy is also mentioned, and his flat pointed out, in the music video "Guided tour of Camden" by Charlie Sloth. They divorce in 1986. He went on the run for three days before being arrested at Great Ormond Street Hospital where he went for medication for diabetes. "Anthony John Hardy has exhibited a degree of depravity in the way he committed these appalling crimes that I personally have never ever come across before." By. The panel ruled that Dr Patel, 63, had taken an inflexible approach to his autopsy and gave only superficial consideration to the possibility Ms White had been strangled. You dont need too many powers of deduction to work out he is the man identified only as Dr Y. There is mention of Dr Patels work in their final report, published in September 2005. [20] Investigators were of the opinion that the body had been cut up with something sharp like a Samurai sword. "Further away in another industrial bin, the police found the right arm belonging to Elizabeth Valad, the left arm and left foot also belonging to Valad, and the lower torso of Bridgette MacClennan." He was supended from all practice in September 2010 for three months after specific findings surrounding three examinations he had conducted. It follows the panel's investigation into three cases dating from 2003 to 2005. The judge passes a sentence of life imprisonment. Dr Freddy Patel is accused . The panel also gave its findings on each specific aspect of Dr Patel's conduct in relation to whether it was irresponsible, not to standard and liable to bring the profession into disrepute. Only you know for sure how your victims met their deaths but the unspeakable indignities to which you subjected the bodies of your last two victims in order to satisfy your depraved and perverted needs are in no doubt.